Development of a Pricing Model
This model creates a "side-by-side" comparison of direct exchange and money (dollars) pricing. It demonstrates how a fixed quantity of money in a system provides more accurate information about the pricing relationships between goods in the system then does either the expansion or contraction of the quantity of money. It also shows how changes in the quantity of money will distort that information.
The next three tabs contain preliminary information about the model and descriptions of its main components. I have outlined the contents of those tabs here:
Assumptions
The model contains the following assumptions:
- Isolation of Factors
- The stocks and flows in this model operate free of external influence.
- Production & Sales
- You, the operator, select the growth rate of production, which determines the sales rate.
- Money
- Initial quantity money is distributed equally. Shoe producers have half; wheat producers have half.
- 100% Exchange
- All good offered for sale get exchanged:
goods for goods, and money for goods.
- Prices
- The quantities of goods exchanged determine direct exchange prices, and the quantities of goods exchanged and the quantity of money determine money prices.
- Definitions
- Inflation: an increase in the quantity of money.
Deflation: a decrease in the quantity of money.
The Model
The primary elements of the model consist of:
- Commodities
- Shoes
Wheat
Money
- Prices
- Direct Exchange
Indirect Exchange (Commodities for Money)
Simulations
The simulations reflect following behaviors over time:
- Sales
- Inventories
- Direct
Exchange Prices
- Money
Supply
- Dollar
Prices
- Price
Conversion
The model represents the behavior of only a very few elements
of an economic system. I have defined very strict limitations on this
system in order to isolate the behavior of those elements. This makes
the model theoretically accurate, even though somewhat unrealistic. The
complexity of economic systems precludes modeling them accurately (in
spite of what your econometric friends will tell you).
See details of The Assumptions on the next tab.
Assumptions
In order to model the prices of goods within a market we must make a few assumptions that strip away the complexity of a normal market and focuses on the goods represented in the model.
Isolation of Factors
- Evenly Rotating Economy
- In order to eliminate external influences I have first assumed that
this segment exists within an otherwise
evenly rotating economy.
The "evenly rotating economy" consists of a market in which all needs get satisfied. In over-simplified terms all supply and demand achieves equilibrium (which,
contrary to classical economics never exists in functioning economies).
- Isolated Segment of Market
- The imaginary market segment that I have created with this model
exchanges pairs of shoes and bushels of wheat. The exchange of goods in
other segments of the market do not influence these two goods.
Production & Sales
- Production Base & Sales Fraction
- I have established the following base production and sales percentages
from which to make calculations.
|
Base Production |
Sales % |
Shoe Production |
50 pairs/mo. |
98.00% |
Wheat Production |
100 bushels/mo. |
95.00% |
- Production & Sales Growth (Decline)
- The current production rate equals the base production rate times the fractional increase compounded by the number of months.
The current production rate times the fractional sales rate yields the
sales rate of the product at the current time. (e.g. with no change in
production, shoe production equals 50 pairs/month times a 98% fractional sales rate
yields sales of 49 pairs/month at each current time throughout the 60
month period.)
Money
The following assumptions regulate the quantity and initial distribution of money:
- Monetary Base
- The money supply begins with 10,000 dollars of money.
-
- Initial Distribution of Money
- The shoe and wheat producers share the initial quantity of money 50/50.
- Fixed Quantity of Money - Simulation 1
- The money supply remains unchanged (at 10,000 dollars) throughout the
60 months.
- Inflation: Increasing Quantity of Money - Simulation 2
- The money supply increases steadily during the inflation/deflation period. (See below.)
- Deflation: Decreasing Quantity of Money - Simulation 3
- The money supply decreases steadily during the inflation/deflation period. (See below.)
- Inflation/Deflation Period
- The expansion (or contraction) of the money supply begins in the month determined by the value set for increase start and lasts for a period determined by the value set for increase duration.
100 % Exchange
In the model the market clears itself.
- Direct Exchange
- All wheat production offered for sale gets exchanged for all shoe
production offered for sale. Because this model tracks production, not producers, the number of producers does not matter.
- Indirect Exchange (Money)
- Because of the evenly rotating economy and the 100% exchange assumption, this market does not
require a form of indirect exchange. I have, however, assumed the use of
indirect exchange (use of money) to demonstrate the relationship to and influence by
changes in the quantity of
money.
At each point in time the sellers of shoes and the sellers of wheat
each have half the available money. In other words each groups exchanges
all their money for the goods of the other group. This makes the direct
exchange and money exchanges consistent.
Prices
The following prices—direct and indirect—result of the market clearing itself:
- Direct Exchange
- Based on the
assumption of full exchange (all of one product for all of another) the model calculates an exchange
ratio (or price.) e.g. an exchange of 60 pairs of shoes for 120 bushels of wheat results in a wheat price of 0.5 pair/bushel or a shoe price of 2 bushels/pair.
- Indirect Exchange (Money)
- Based on the 100% exchange assumption the dollar prices for any period equals a ratio of one half the quantity of money to the quantity of a specific good, e.g. With a total quantity of money of $10,000 an exchange of $5,000 for 50 pairs of shoes results in a money price of $100/pair.
Definitions
- Inflation:
- an increase in the quantity of money.
- Deflation:
- a decrease in the quantity of money.
Let"s examine The Model on the next tab
The Model
This tab provides more detail of the elements of this model:
Commodities
This model contains three commodities: Shoes, Wheat, and Money. It shows the flow of shoes and wheat from production through sale. The quantities of these two commodities that do not get sold accumulate in their respective inventories. The flow of money either increases or decreases the quantity of money in stock. The following outline briefly describes the representation of these commodities:
Shoes
- Shoe Production
- Shoes get produced at a rate of a number of pairs per month based on the following two variables:
- base
shoe production (Fixed)
- This variable provides the base rate of shoe production.
- annual
fractional shoe increases (Adjustable)
- This variable provides the annualized fractional rate by
which shoe production increases. - Plus or minus
20%es beginning with the base rate.
- Shoe Sales
- Shoe sales amount to a fraction of the shoe production based on the following variable:
- fractional
shoe sales rate (Fixed)
- The fraction of shoe production sold each month.
- Shoes (Inventories)
- The stock of shoes accumulates based on the production rate less the sales rate.
Wheat
- Wheat Production
- Wheat gets produced at a rate of a number of bushels per month based on the following two variables:
- base
wheat production (Fixed)
- This variable provides the base rate of wheat production.
- annual
fractional wheat increases (Adjustable)
- This variable provides the annualized fractional rate by
which wheat production increases beginning with the base rate.
- Wheat Sales
- Wheat sales amount to a fraction of the wheat production based on the following variable:
- fractional
wheat sales rate (Fixed)
- The fraction of wheat production sold each month.
- Wheat (Inventories)
- The stock of wheat accumulates based on the production rate less the sales rate.
Money
- Increase rate
- This flow increases the quantity of money at a rate of a number of dollars per month determined by the following variables:
- annual
fractional money increase rate (Adjustable)
- The annualized fractional rate at which the quantity of
money increase (or decreases). - Plus or minus 15%
- Increase
Start (Fixed for these simulations)
- The quantity of money does not begin to increase (or decrease) until this month.
- Increase
Duration (Fixed for these simulations)
- The number of months during which the quantity of money increases (or decreases).
- Money Stock
- Beginning with 10,000 dollars the quantity of money increases (or decreases) each month depending on the increase rate described above.
Prices
The model calculated the prices for shoes and wheat in terms of direct and indirect (money) exchange. It makes these calculations based on the assumptions reiterated below:
Direct Exchange Prices
- Shoes - Bushels/Pair
- Total wheat sales divided by total shoe sales, given the assumption of a 100% exchange. This calculation gives the number of bushels of wheat exchanged for each pair of shoes.
- Wheat - Pairs/Bushel
- Total shoe sales divided by total wheat sales, given the assumption of a 100% exchange. This calculation gives the number of pairs of shoes exchanged for each
bushel of wheat .
Money Prices
- Shoes - Dollars/Pair
- The number of dollars exchanged for each pair of shoes, given the assumption that half the money stock gets exchanged for all the shoes sold.
- Wheat - Dollars/Bushel
- The number of dollars exchanged for each bushel of wheat, given the assumption that half the money stock gets exchanged for all the wheat sold.
Note: Each of the three scenarios in this presentation use the same embedded model. Since the model reloads when you open a new page, you will need to reset the adjustable variables.
Next, a brief description of the simulations on the next tab...
Simulations
When
you click the "Run Simulation" button, you will see the following behavior-over-time charts:
- Sales
- Sales rates vary based on
fractional sales rates and production rates.
- Inventories
- Because producers do not
sell all production, inventories of shoes and wheat increase over time.
- Direct
Exchange Prices
- This chart reflects the
exchange rate from two perspectives - i.e. wheat price: pairs/bushel and shoe
price: bushels/pair. (The wheat price indicates how many pairs of shoes it
takes to buy a bushel of wheat. The shoe price indicates how many bushels of wheat
it takes to buy a pair of shoes.)
- Money
Supply
- Same criteria as direct
exchange using money
- Dollar
Prices
- The dollar price of shoes
based on shoe sales and transaction parameters. The dollar price of wheat
based on shoe sales and transaction parameters.
- Price
Conversion
- Converts the dollar price of
shoes to a wheat price for shoes, and converts the dollar price of wheat to a
shoe price for wheat. Done for the curious to assure the calculations
reconcile.